View Full Version : Ignorance and little knowledge for Whabis and Salafi

Ya Mustafa
09-26-2011, 03:48 PM

The Holy Prophet Muhammad (sal-lal-lahu alai hi wa sallam) said: “Whoever brings forth an innovation into our religion which is not part of it, it is rejected”. The Holy Prophet Muhammad (sal-lal-lahu alai hi wa sallam) also said: “Beware of inventive matters for every invention is an innovation and every innovation is evil”. Those who quote these two Ahadith claim that the word “Kul” which means “EVERY” or “ALL” which is mentioned in the above two Ahadith is used to include everything, i.e. all kinds of innovations or “Bid’ah” without any exception. They conclude therefore, that all innovations are “evil”.

By stating such an ILL-FATED STATEMENT, they have in fact accused the scholars (Ulama) of the Muslim World of committing ‘evil’ innovations, particularly Hadrat Umar [ (Radiallahu Ta’ala Anhu) ] However, they quickly respond and say: No, we did not mean the Companions (Sahaba Ikraam). In reply to that we say, yes, indeed you did so, because you said “EVERY” or “ALL” innovations are “EVIL”.

And you (Wahabbi / “Salafi’s”) have rejected what the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sal-lal-lahu alai hi wa sallam) himself approved, i.e.”Taraweeh Prayers”.

We will now quote before you many actions which were not carried out during the life of Prophet Muhammad (sal-lal-lahu alai hi wa sallam) but were in fact done following his demise by his Companions [RA].


Hadrat Zaid bin Thabit said: Prophet Muhammad (sal-lal-lahu alai hi wa sallam) had passed away and the Qur’an has not been compiled into one book! In fact, it was Hadrat Umar who told Hadrat Abu Bakr [RA] to collect the Qur’an. Hadrat Abu Bakr was hesitant at first and he actually said, “How could we do something which the Prophet himself never did”. Hadrat Umar replied, “BUT BY ALLAH IT IS A GOOD THING”. Hadrat Zaid then said, “Hadrat Umar [RA] kept coming back and forth until Hadrat Abu Bakr sent after him and assigned him the task of compiling the Qur’an.”


Imam Bayhaqi said that Bibi Ayesha [ (Radiallahu Ta’ala Anhu). ] a wife of the Holy Prophet (sal-lal-lahu alai hi wa sallam) said that Prophet Ibrahim’s Station (Footprint) was attached to “KAABA” during the Prophet’s and Abu Bakr’s time. It was not until the time of Hazrat Umar (Radiallahu Ta’ala Anhu). who changed its original position. Ibn Hajar the great Muhaddith said: “None of the companions raised any objection against Hazrat Umar (Radiallahu Ta’ala Anhu). for doing so and he was the first person to cover Prophet Ibrahim’s Station (Footprint) in the state it is now.”


Imam Baihaqi narrated that Sayyiduna al-Saa’eb bin Zaid said: “The first call (Adhaan) for Friday Prayer commenced when the Imam sat on the Pulpit (Mimbar). This was the practice during the Prophet’s, Hazrat Abu Bakr’s and Hazrat Umar’s time. But when Hazrat Uthman [RA] came, he introduced the second Azaan.”

4. SENDING PRAISE AND SALAAMS UPON THE PROPHET (sal-lal-lahu alai hi wa sallam)

This was first introduced by Hazrat Ali [ (Radiallahu Ta’ala Anhu). ] and he used to teach it to people of his time. Ibn Jabir mentioned that in his book called “Tah’theeb al-Aa’thar” so did Imam Tabari, ibi Assem and Yaqoub bin Shaibah.


Imam Tabari said that ibn Masoud used to read after saying “As Salaam Alaikum Warahmatullahi Wabarakaatuhu”, “As Salaam Alaina Min Rabenna” (Peace be upon us from our Lord).


Bukhari and Muslim both narrated that ibn Umar [RA] use to read “Bimillah al-Rahman al-Rahim” before Tasha’hud.

All the above Companions have in fact introduced innovations which they have deemed beneficial and which were not practised during the life of the Prophet (sal-lal-lahu alai hi wa sallam). Hence, that these innovations where brought about in acts of worship! What then would you say about these renowned Companions? Are they going to be classified among those who practise “evil” innovations!

As for their (Bin Baz, etc.) other statement which is even worse that the first one, where it is alleged by them that in the religion of Islam there is no such thing as “Good Innovation” or “Bid’ah”. Let us quote the opinion of the most renowned scholars of Islam regarding this issue.

1. Imam al-Hafiz al-Nawawi [RA] said in Vol.6, p.21 in his “Commentary on Sahih al-Bukhari”: “What the Prophet (sallal laahu alaihi wasallam) meant when he said “very” or “all” innovations, is that it is general but restricted, i.e. that most innovations are “evil” but not “all”.” In “Tahdhib al-Asma wal Lugat” Bid’ah is explained as follows: “Bid’ah in Shari’ah is the invention of that which was not there in the period of the Messenger of Allah, and it is divided into two categories Hasanah (or good) and Qabihah (or evil)”.

2. Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani [RA] who explained Sahih al-Bukhari said: “Every action which was not in practice at the Prophet’s time is called or known as Innovation, however, there are those which are classified as ‘Good’ and there are those which are contrary to that”.

3. Imam Abu-Na’im said that he heard Imam Ibrahim al-Junaid say that he heard Imam Shafi’i [RA] say: “The new things that are brought about are two kinds. One kind is that which brought about, inconsistent with something in the Qur’an or the Sunnah or with some Athaar or I’jma. This the category of Bid’ah Dalalah (heretic innovation). The second kind is that which is brought about from good things which are consistent with any of the above”.

4. Imam of Imams Izzuddin Ibn Abd al-Salaam [RA] writes in his book “al-Qawa’aid”: “Bid’ah is divided into Wajib, Haram, Mandub, Makruh and Mabah. And the way to know which category it belongs to, is to examine it together with the laws of Shari’ah. If it falls in with the laws that deal with what is Wajib, then it is Wajib. If with those laws that deal with Haram, then it is Haram. If with the laws dealing with what is Mandub, then it is Mandub. If with the laws dealing with what is Makruh, then it is Makruh. If with the laws dealing with what is Mubah, then it is Mubah”.

Following the examination of the statements of these highly renowned scholars of Islam, we ask: How is it then that what is alleged that the word “Kul” or “every” includes all kinds of innovations or “Bid’ah” regardless? And where in the religion of Islam is it stated that there is no “good Bid’ah” or “good Innovation.” Hence, the Messenger of Allah has said: “Whoever introduces a good innovation into the religion of Islam, will be granted due reward for it and the reward of those who acts upon it without any reduction in their deeds.”
From this hadith we find that every Muslim is entitled to introduce a “good Bid’ah or Innovation” as long as it conforms with the test mentioned earlier, even though the Messenger of Allah did not do it, preach it or practice, in order that he/she could increase the deeds of goodness and rewards.

Hassan Raza
12-26-2011, 08:07 AM
good post jazakALLAH

Rizwan Attari
12-15-2012, 07:14 AM
nice post thx...